Climate Action Finance
This page is about how to finance capital improvements to churches and other buildings, in order to save energy and greenhouse gas emissions.
Climate Action Finance is needed in support of the Diocese of London’s Climate Action Projects, for example solar panels, biomass heating and heat pumps.
We aim through such projects to cut the energy use of churches across the Diocese by at least 42% by 2020 and 80% by 2050. See also Route 2050 and Generic Building Solutions.
The primary motive for a Christian church to reducing energy consumption, improve the energy efficiency of its buildings and install renewable energy should be care for God’s Creation.
- Stewardship of scarce resources, especially the gifts of a congregation, in pursuance of the Church’s Mission is an important consideration;
- Stewardship of energy and care for Creation are key aspects of Mission in themselves.
Financial viability may influence whether a scheme can go ahead. However, so long as the capital can be raised and repayments made on time, yielding a return over and above that might not be the main incentive.
Project finance requires both capital to pay for works, and income for interest and paying back instalments on capital.
- Capital may be sought from grants, bank loans, the Carbon Trust, loans from the Diocese, Area grants or loans or community schemes. Owners including churches may form cooperatives with each other, to share and potentially reduce costs; some parish trusts may contribute;
- Some schemes work on the ‘pay as you save’ principle – the savings in outgoings by saving energy support repayments. The government’s Renewable Heat Incentive and Smart Export Guarantee (see below) may also assist.
Always bear in mind VAT, and fuel costs.
Grants are harder to come by than they once were, though some sources may still be open.
Here a few:
Some grants sources are public or government funded. Projects taking grants from public funds such as the Lottery are ineligible for subsidies like the Renewable Heat Incentive, and even for the Smart Export Guarantee even though that isn’t a subsidy, it’s a payment for electricity generated. For larger amounts, the Heritage Lottery Fund may also require carbon footprinting of associated utilities consumption and travel.
See also national Church of England website.
The Government’s Feed-in Tariff was closed to new entrants at the end of March 2019, with a further year for those who have pre-registered.
It appears that premises already benefitting from the Feed-in Tariff will continue to do so for the period guaranteed on entry.
Some churches and other premises have pre-registered for the Feed-in Tariff for their proposed new solar panels, and should therefore receive the Tariff so long as the system is installed, commissioned and registered by the end of March 2020.
Smart Export Guarantee
The Government has now promised this new scheme requiring most electricity suppliers to offer a tariff for payment for electricity generated on site and exported to the national grid. This is to come into force on 1st January 2020.
The scheme will not be retrospective. Only electricity generated after that date will benefit. So it will be advisable for new solar PV installations to pause until 2020, unless they have pre-registered for the Feed-in Tariff (see above).
Existing beneficiaries will also, obviously, not benefit from the SEG too.
See Smart Export Guarantee.
Renewable Heat Incentive
The Renewable Heat Incentive (RHI) is a government scheme of subsidies for generation of heat by any of the following technologies:
- Biomass (boilers fuelled by wood or other plant matter, usually for chips or pellets);
- Ground and air source heat pumps (which extract heat from the ground or the air);
- Solar heat collectors (solar thermal heat or hot water);
- Biomethane and biogas (see comments on anaerobic digestion above).
The Renewable Heat Incentive may apply to a non-domestic property, or a domestic property.
For churches and church halls, it will be biomass heating and heat pumps (ground source and perhaps air source) that are mainly applicable.
The Renewable Heat Incentive currently works by paying the owner of a renewable heating system per kWh of output, rates being index linked and guaranteed for a fixed term of 20 years.
To benefit from the RHI you normally need a heat meter.
The scheme is not straightforward: up to date expert advice is a must.
The Green Investment Group (in limited circumstances) and Triodos Bank may be able to offer finance.
The Carbon Trust and Siemens Financial Services have partnered to offer finance for energy-saving investment to UK businesses and other organisations, for which some churches may qualify – though the criteria are quite tight.
Where funding from other sources still falls short of a parish’s needs, the Diocese may be able to offer loans. These are on favourable terms including interest rates.
When applying for support for a Climate Action Project, please also seek advice from the Head of Environment and Sustainability before making an application.
See Diocesan loans.
Area grants or loans
Funds available to your Episcopal Area may enable a grant and/or a loan for urgent works such as boiler replacement.
Each Area will have slightly different criteria.
See Area grants and loans.
Have you thought of clubbing together in your own deanery, or forming a cooperative with other parishes that you link to?
Where permitted by the purposes and articles of association of a trust, it may be possible to lend to a local project at a rate higher than the trust can earn on deposit, but lower than any rate at which the project could borrow.
For advice, contact the Financial and Trust Accountants. Where the London Diocesan Fund is a trustee, its consent will be required.
Community energy schemes have been developed with the aim of harnessing income from renewable energy to drive local regeneration.
It is well to be prepared and ready when such offers come along, to react in a very short timescales!
There are issues to be worked through first, such as:
- Scale. A single church or church hall may be too small to support installations of the necessary capacity. The principle of community cooperation implies that groups of organisations and buildings or householders are contributing. It’s worth sizing up the potential for such a collaboration in your area;
- Ownership. Is it a precondition that any installations, e.g. solar panels, will be cooperatively owned? Any church under the faculty jurisdiction will need permission from the Diocesan Chancellor for the terms and conditions proposed. In the case of a church hall or other property under trust, the consent of trustees and in many cases the London Diocesan Fund will be required;
- Is the funding a grant, or a commercial loan on a ‘senior’ or ‘mezzanine’ basis (which can mean a charge on a property)? It is not possible to place a charge on premises subject to the legal effects of consecration.
- Assignment of income. There may be a requirement for Feed-in Tariffs, and/or savings in purchased energy costs to be recycled for community benefit. A church will need to be satisfied that its own resources are being stewarded appropriately, against the value of its contribution to the common effort
- Viability. A realistic assessment of long term income and outgoings, the return on capital and the surplus expected for ‘recycling’ is essential as a valid basis to go forward. Any interest payments must be taken into consideration.
Nevertheless we want our churches to play our full part, and to take advantage of appropriate initiatives.
Approved alterations to listed buildings no longer qualify for zero rating.
However, the government’s approved Listed Places of Worship Grants Scheme (LPWGS), which in effect refunds part of the VAT on repairs, can include approved alterations to listed churches as well as repairs. This scheme remains open at least until March 2021.
Installing certain ‘energy-saving materials’ (so-called) are charged VAT at the reduced rate of 5%, in respect of some residential buildings. This includes insulation and draught stripping, and also renewable energy installations including solar panels, also controls for central heating and hot water systems.
Churches no longer benefit from this concession on their VAT.
See also Parliament’s briefing on VAT and churches.
Fuel and power
For non-business charities including most churches (and for domestic purposes/residential premises), fuel and power are eligible for the reduced VAT rate of 5%.
To talk through any project and how to fund it, contact the Head of Environment and Sustainability, the Parish Property Support Team or your Archdeacon.
Also contact the Diocese’s Fundraising Team.